Echoes in the Darkness (1987)

  Echoes In The Darkness

  Joseph Wambaugh

  *

  Author's Note

  I First Became Involved With The So-Called Main Line Murder Case in 1981, when it was already two years old and still unsolved. I traveled to Pennsylvania and interviewed many people, one of the most memorable being William Bradfield with whom I dined in Philadelphia. Another was Sergeant Joseph VanNort of the Pennsylvania State Police who invited me to his mountain cabin for a weekend to discuss the investigation.

  Convinced from all I learned that this case of murder and disappearance would never be heard in a court of law, I decided to abandon the book and return home. Sergeant VanNort tried to convince me that I was wrong, and in the end, I was.

  In 1986 I was back in Pennsylvania on the same case, interviewing more people and attending a murder trial involving well over a hundred witnesses. The Main Line Murder Case is probably unique in the history of American law enforcement. A team of police investigators was assigned to a single investigation and worked it every day from early summer 1979 to early summer 1986. They worked on nothing else for seven years.

  Since two of the characters in this true story are named Susan, I've elected to refer to Susan Myers at all times as "Sue." I've changed the name of two peripheral characters. This was done to discourage frivolous litigation, which is, these days, a by-product of nonfiction.

  Gothic: a late 18th century and early 19th century style of fiction characterized by historical and picturesque settings, an atmosphere of mystery, gloom, and terror, supernatural or fantastic occurrences, and violent and macabre events. -The Random House Dictionary

  I mate with my free kind upon the crags;

  the hidden recesses Have heard the echo of my heels, in the cool light, in the darkness.

  -ezra pound

  PROLOGUE:

  There was always a taste for Gothic in the original colonies, particularly in that historic territory that lies west of Philadelphia, and east of Lancaster where Amish farmers still resist the 20th century.

  Schoolchildren of the commonwealth of Pennsylvania are told that the springtime explosion of red, white and blue on the mournfully lovely countryside was caused by the sacrifice of Revolutionary dead. The tulip is blood-scailet, the dogwood ^one-white, the iris a visceral blue. Thus, the flora is a memorial to the patriots, or so the schoolmasters say.

  The haunt of history is everywhere. "The Main Line" of the Philadelphia commuter train slashes east and west near the old battleground where soldiers wrote of corpse-eating wolves that could outhowl the wind. Local schoolchildren envision bloody footprints in the snow, and gaunt specters with ice-locked muskets, their feet wrapped in rags, led by General Washington who denied himself shelter so long as his starving soldiers had to sleep in the wilderness.

  Its a land of splendid trees. When William Penn arrived in 1682 he marveled at the trees: black walnut, cedar, ash, hickory, sassafras, beech. The oaks are formidable: red, white and black. Some trees, 250 years old, are local treasures. There are ancient buttonwoods, _ yellow pines, firs and red maples. And of course, there's hemlock.

  A great oak still stands that was used as a gibbet after the Battle of Brandywine where in 1777 Washington suffered a defeat. The wretched victims of the gibbet were spies, or so their executioners claimed. Their white dangling bodies turned iron-gray and then black against the colorless sky and parchment leaves of that hanging oak.

  Not surprisingly, its a land of antiques and collectors. Tables in Main Line mansions and manor houses are often made of split slab, with round legs set in auger holes. Ancient nails of all kinds are treasured collectibles, some shaped like tiny piano mallets.

  This was a land of forges and furnaces. Iron was always cherished. "There is an abidingness about iron," a settler wrote, "and most things made from it." Its impossible not to feel this abidingness along The Main Line.

  Youngsters from all over America come here to attend prestigious prep schools and academies. For higher learning there's Swarthmore, Haverfbrd, Villanova, Bryn Mawr and others, as well as several seminaries marked by split-rail or white-pine or iron gates, surrounded by native trees that turn bronze and fiery during Indian summer. The trees lie side by side with pretty autumn flowers whose names are sinister: redhot poker, white snakeroot. Its hard to miss the taste for Gothic.

  One can be lulled by a sense of the "abidingness" on suburban roads, especially on cloudy days when vivid colors are muted, and cheerful light shines from a Georgian mansion, a French chiteau, a colonial manor house. There's something reassuring about the craft and labor that's turned so many ancient carriage houses and barns and stables into enduring homes of brick, stone and cedar. But just past any turn in the road, there might be another kind of structure made of the local moss-green stone called serpentine. A slated spire or iron-gray vaulted arch might loom suddenly. It'll only be a church or public meeting house or a distant manse, but the medieval stone undermines the pastoral in this heartland of Friends, as the English Quakers were called.

  Perhaps the Gothic Revival was inspired by the mercenaries who brought the warrior arts. German professionals taught the citizen soldiers the value of cold steel at the end of a musket. Bloodied French veterans scoffed at tales of Lafayette's gallantry. They massacred for money. In the early days native Indians were never certain whether they should murder for the invaders or risk being murdered by them. In the land of patriots and Friends there were always pitiless renegades. They were as medieval as serpentine stone.

  But even with their taste for Gothic the locals were bewildered by the series of irrational and "evil" events that destroyed many lives and led to the most massive homicide investigation Pennsylvania had ever experienced.

  Chapter 1

  The Poet

  "I wasn't the first colleague to fall for Bill Bradfield, not by a long shot," Sue Myers said. "He had a way. He was intense yet boyish. He was articulate and erudite but wasn't afraid to show affection. He might suddenly just put his arm around your shoulder when he was talking ever so passionately about something as mundane as a lesson plan for advanced students. He was handsy, but it seemed so natural. Some people found it endearing.

  "He dreamed of visiting the sacred places that T. S. Eliot and Ezra Pound visited when they toured Europe," she remembered. "I never pretended to understand Pounds poetry. I attempted to read The Cantos, but I couldn't decipher them. I thought Bill Bradfield was the most brilliant teacher I'd ever met. He was interested in art and music and literature. He was interested in everything. The students loved him, and pretty soon so did I."

  The newspapers never got her age right when they wrote about her. Sue Myers was older than reported. Born in May, 1940, she was seven years younger than William S. Bradfield,

  Jr.

  Sue Myers met William Bradfield when she came to teach at Upper Merion Senior High School in the fell of 1963, and within a year they were lovers. But being the lover of Bill Bradfield had its drawbacks. Newspaper accounts in later years would refer to him as the "Rasputin" of Upper Merion, but if so, somebody must've misplaced the mad monks rampant glands. Sue Myers was a virgin when she began dating Bill Bradfield and thought for several months she might remain one.

  "He never made me feel he was after a sexual fix," she said. "We hardly did more than lass for a long while."

  When she first dated him he wore a hand-me-down suit that had belonged to a dead uncle, yet on his wrist was a top-of-theline Omega. When he was away from home he'd stay in places where at night the wallpaper wiggled and shimmied, yet once he ran out and bought seven pairs of Nettleton shoes because someone told them they were good. He kept Sue Myers so confused it was literally months before sh
e thought she understood his marital status. And then she was wrong.

  He was a whole lot of work, this teacher. She'd learn about him, but a little at a time.

  One of the things she learned early was that Bill Bradfield was the only son of a retired corporate executive who owned a nice piece of land and a 19th-century farmhouse near Downingtown. His father had worked for Western Electric and had been transferred often in his career. Bill Bradfield told her that he'd been enrolled in thirteen different schools before entering Haverford College in the heart of The Main Line, considered part of the "Little Ivy League," along with Colby and Amherst, and sister schools like Swarthmore and Bryn Mawr.

  It was always painful for him to recall his boyhood relationship with his father. It seemed young Bill Bradfield could never perform any task well enough to suit an aggressive, overachieving businessman. One day the boy was determined to do an expert job of trimming the hedge in their yard. He dug a hole, and after measuring precisely, planted a pole at each end of the hedge to mark the desired height. Then he tied a string between the two pencil marks and trimmed the hedge as "flat as a table top." He'd labored for hours, and when he was finished he nervously awaited his father's judgment. The executive pointed out that his son had forgotten to take into consideration the terrain, which sloped twelve inches from one end of the hedge to the other. Put an egg on this table and you'd better like omelets.

  "Bradfields never forget," Sue Myers said. "Bill grew to be a very unforgiving man."

  Bill Bradfield stood six feet three inches tall and weighed two hundred pounds, with a chest and shoulders he'd developed as a college wrestler. He had brooding blue eyes, shaded by overhanging eyebrows that often caught bronze highlights when he cocked his head in a dreamy pose. His gaze was so intense it could transfix, so his blue eyes were variously described as "poetic," "icy" or "hypnotic," depending upon his moods.

  He had coppery blond hair and in the early days of their relationship, a romantic D. H. Lawrence beard that could look like a clump of seaweed when he was in his "active" phase.

  His active phase, according to Sue Myers, took place in the spring. "The juices would flow," she said, and he'd become about as predictable as a Chinese earthquake.

  Sue Myers was more than a foot shorter than her secret lover and weighed a little over a hundred pounds. She was a brunette with a small mouth and grayish teeth and dark selfconscious eyes that darted like a pair of hummingbirds.

  She was not a dreamer. Sue Myers was a practical woman who knew her limitations and couldn't believe that she was being chosen by (it would become an Upper Merion cliche) the most "charismatic" teacher in the district. She was only modestly attractive, but Bill Bradfield had never been known to pursue beautiful women. In the true Romantic spirit, he said that he sought "the beauty of the soul."

  One of the first things anyone ever learned about Bill Bradfield was that he was crazy about Ezra Pound. Early in their love affair he told Sue Myers how it had happened.

  Unable to get his academic bearings in his undergraduate days at Haverford, Bill Bradfield read a book that altered the course of his life. It was ABC of Reading, by Ezra Pound. Like all of the poet's work, it was obscure, arcane, filled with Greek, Latin and classical allusion. The young man didn't understand the book but was deeply moved by it.

  He learned that Ezra Pound was still confined at St. Elizabeths mental hospital in Washington, D.C., having barely escaped a charge of treason for lending support to Benito Mussolini. Before Pound was released, Bill Bradfield visited him and managed to ingratiate himself. He ran errands and visited the Library of Congress on Pound's behalf. He was, in a sense, on the scene when Pound wrote his most famous work within the walls of the asylum. While Ezra Pound was studying Confucius and writing The Cantos, Bill Bradfield wanted to help his master escape and to hide the poet in the Bradfield attic.

  Sue Myers was never certain how the undergraduate's plans ran aground, but the upshot was that Bill Bradfield returned to Haverford inspired to complete his undergraduate and graduate degrees and pursue a life of contemplation and poetry. Though born and raised a Quaker, he was, through Pounds influence, deeply interested in Catholicism and the writings of

  Thomas Aquinas. From then on, when asked his religion, he would say, "I'm a Quaker-Confucian-Catholic.''

  Sue Myers alwaysbelieved that he would never have chosen her if she hadn't been a virgin. Bill Bradfield always spoke of chastity, and celibacy was one of the things he admired most about the Roman Catholic clergy.

  In later years, she would often say, "The feet of the matter is, Bill Bradfield would have been much happier as a monk."

  But he was far from monkish back in those days. Sue Myers had to endure many other women but he would always vow to repent. And she would forgive.

  "When he talked of love to me," she recalled, "I felt I was the only person in the universe for him. When he'd hold me, I was convinced of it beyond all doubt."

  Alas, there were several other teachers at Upper Merion equally convinced. Bill Bradfield sought the soul of one of them but had settled for her body when her husband found out about it and warned Bill to desist at once.

  The next thing the husband knew, the former college wrestler came crashing through his front door and chased him down the hall while the wife, wrapped in a towel, stood screaming. According to the police report, Bill Bradfield punched the husband twenty times, breaking his nose, thereby adding injury to insult, as he bellowed, "Never interfere with me again!"

  He was charged with aggravated assault and battery, but charges were dropped after he agreed to turn over $500 in bail money for the victim's medical expenses.

  Sue Myers heard all the stories, but she wanted this man. She intended to marry him and have children with him. So they talked of living together, but he had one little caveat: their arrangement would have to remain secret. She said she'd consider it.

  There was a very good reason for the secrecy, he told her. The school district might charge them with moral turpitude if it was found they were living together out of wedlock.

  And when she suggested that they could easily eliminate that problem, he had a lot of complex and confusing reasons why marriage could not take place. Not yet.

  In the first place, he confessed, he was already "sort of married." Twice. And he had children by both ladies. It seems that he'd met Fran in college, and being young and inexperienced, he decided to live with her, a daring decision at that time. There wasn't sufficient thought given by either of them, he had to admit in retrospect. There had been other things occupying him: a martyred poet locked in an asylum, for instance. Anyway, they had two boys, Martin and William, born a year apart. When the boys were five or six, Fran left. (He was very vague about this part.) And then along came Muriel.

  She wasn't as pretty as Fran, and of course she wasn't his intellectual equal. She was tall and thin and had a long angular face. Not a great housekeeper either, but she was a born mother, and his two lads needed a mother. He and Muriel struck a bargain and entered into a living arrangement. Another "common-law" marriage, so to speak. Part of the agreement required that he sire another child for Muriel. She wanted to bear a child with "his looks and brains." So David was born.

  All of the kids lived with Muriel in a house he owned in Chester County. He saw to their support, but he still wasn't actually married, he said. But it was his nature to be "spiritually married," joined by conscience until the boys were old enough to make their own way. So he asked Sue Myers to be patient and remain a secret lover until a better time.

  Sue Myers was nothing if not patient. Not many people ever knew they were lovers. He always claimed they were "close friends." It took an extraordinary capacity for secrecy to pull this off over the years. It took an extraordinary capacity for obedience on the part of his half-pint Sancho Panza.

  The most memorable time in their life together, Sue Myers would later say, the year that marked a profound change in their relationship, was the sabbatic
al year of 1972-1973 when they finally realized their dream. They began a pilgrimage to Europe to see all the sacred places of Ezra Pound.

  Sue Myers had tried to prepare for the intellectual onslaught by studying The Pound Era by Hugh Kenner, but to her the poets work was about as lucid as a polygraph chart. She was informed at the last minute that he had decided to bring along his two eldest sons, now restless teenagers. And she had to promise not to make a single slip in word or deed by revealing to his sons that she was anything more than another faculty member who happened to be traveling to the same places. By then, they had only been lovers for eight years.

  The highlight of the journey was to have been an audience with the Master, if they could arrange it. But at the first stop, London, they got the horrendous news: Ezra Pound had died in Venice, literally in the arms of his mistress.

  Bill Bradfield went off alone to make grief noises. When he returned he could only say, "A fellow poet has died!"

  And that death set the stage for a maniacal tour of the sacred places. The disciple wanted relics. The four of them-Bill Bradfield, Sue Myers, and the two boys-careened around the Continent in a rented Volkswagen bus while he hungered to see every site where the bard had so much as walked.

  They rattled into Rapallo where Pound had been arrested at the close of World War II for treasonable collaboration with the Fascists. They tracked down a former friend of the poet who still lived in the same house she had occupied as a child when she was Pounds neighbor. The woman couldn't speak English but managed to understand Bill Bradfield's Spanish.

  She revealed to him a treasure trove. Her house was filled with books by and about Pound, and photos, and memorabilia. It was a day of joy!

  They found a prison compound near Pisa and visited Ezra Pounds former cellblock as other pilgrims visit Lourdes. Bill Bradfield clipped a piece of the barbed wire that encircled the now defunct compound and treated that snippet like a sliver from the True Cross.